article archive
April 2007
WCA rebukes BBC for biased report
The World Chiropractic Alliance (WCA) contacted the British
Broadcasting Corporation (BBC) after learning of its planned
investigative report on chiropractors accused of fraud
for correcting subluxations. The doctors are among a small
but growing number of DCs in the United Kingdom who no
longer call themselves "chiropractors" because
of the way the term is being used in that country. Instead,
they identify themselves as Spinal Specialists who focus
on the detection and correction of vertebral subluxations
and do not offer medical services to patients.
The BBC report
was apparently spurred by complaints by members of the
GCC (General Chiropractic Council, the UK's government
body) and the British Chiropractic Association (BCA), a
member of the World Federation of Chiropractic.
In a process
similar to one used by the popular US news program, "60 Minutes," the BBC news department
sent three patients to GCC member doctors for examinations.
According to information received by the WCA, none were given
subluxation‑specific examinations or x‑rays,
yet all were categorized as "perfectly healthy."
The
three people were then sent to Spinal Specialist Christian
Farthing, who detected subluxations in each of them and recommended
chiropractic adjustments.
Farthing attended the University at
the Royal Melbourne Institute of Technology in Australia and
earned a double degree in Bachelor of Applied Science (Clinical
Science) and Bachelor of Chiropractic Science. He practiced
as a chiropractor in the UK from 2000-2001, but, after a dispute
with the new GCC, his license was suspended. He continued to
provide subluxation-corrective services as a "spinal
specialist" and
was suspended for an additional three years.
He rebelled against
the medical stance of the GCC, asking: "Why
should the rest of the world benefit from spinal correction
and wellness care, but not the UK? Why should the UK miss
out? Put simply, this is what they want to occur in Britain."
In 2003, he opened the Ideal Spine Centre and became a Distinguished
Fellow of CBP for Clinical and Spinal Biomechanics. He is
currently working closely with the international program
'The Wellness Practice' and Dr. James Chestnut from Canada.
Farthing is also the leading author of the book, "The
World's Best Kept Health Secret Revealed."
He is not alone in walking away from the GCC and BCA since
both organizations fail to recognize the traditional non-medical
view of chiropractic and repeatedly discriminate against
and harass subluxation-centered doctors. Although purporting
to be "chiropractic" organizations, the word "subluxation" does
not appear on either group's website. The BCA defines chiropractic
in medical terms as a treatment of "conditions that
are due to problems with the joints, ligaments, tendons and
nerves of the body, particularly those of the spine.
In its
second letter to the BBC, the WCA protested the reporter's
reliance on BCA doctors to make chiropractic determinations.
Writing for the WCA, President Terry A. Rondberg, DC, told
the BBC reporter that her repeated references to the "three
perfectly healthy people" in the investigation "clearly
indicates a misconception about what it means to be 'healthy.'"
He went on to explain that, "Most
people think being 'healthy' means a lack of symptoms. If you
aren't in pain at the moment, or aren't exhibiting some outward
sign of a disease, you are 'healthy.' But, according to the
World Health Organization, health is 'a state of complete physical,
mental, and social well being and not merely the absence
of disease or infirmity.'"
He added: "The practitioners who examined the three
individuals did not conduct chiropractic examinations geared
to detecting vertebral subluxations. How can they or
you state categorically the three subjects
were 'perfectly healthy?' The doctors who worked with you
on this report also probably did not conduct examinations
for such ailments as pre-diabetes, ovarian cancer,
heart disease or hepatitis C, all of which are commonly called
'silent killers' and require specialized medical diagnostic
procedures. If one of these three people has any of these
problems, would you still call them 'perfectly healthy' simply
because the doctors you hired to examine them failed to find
anything?
"The only thing that can be said decisively about the
three people used in your investigative report," Rondberg
continued, "is that the examinations they were given
did not uncover any medical problems. However, until they
went to Dr. Farthing, they had not been tested for vertebral
subluxations. There are thousands of chiropractors around
the world who focus solely on detecting and correcting vertebral
subluxations. The fact that the doctors you chose to aid
in your BBC report did not find them speaks volumes about
their position outside the mainstream of the global chiropractic
community."
The truth of that statement is supported by
a 2006 survey of British chiropractors, the vast majority of
whom said they had no confidence in the GCC to regulate the
profession.
The World Chiropractic Alliance also countered
other criticisms leveled at Farthing and subluxation-centered
chiropractors in the UK, including accusations that offering
pre-payment
wellness care plans were unethical and that x-rays
should never be given in a chiropractic office.
At press time,
it was not known whether the BBC would air the investigative
report or if it would include information received from the
WCA.
"We sincerely hope the BBC upholds its high journalistic
standards and realizes that it is being manipulated by the
anti-chiropractic forces at work in Britain," stated
Dr. Rondberg. "The GCC and BCA are working hand in hand
with the World Federation of Chiropractic to change the entire
definition of chiropractic, to turn the profession into a
medical therapy that distances itself from the traditional
purpose of chiropractic. We are seeing this happen in other
WFC groups and subluxation-centered doctors around
the globe have to unite in our opposition to the WFC organizations
if we want to preserve the unique identity of our profession.
If we don't, doctors of chiropractic will end up being nothing
more than second-rate osteopaths who manipulate the
spine to treat back pain in adults. What a loss that would
be to the world!"